Apple Needs To Move The iPad Beyond The Toddler Stage
The world’s second-most-valuable company, which is introducing new models on Tuesday, should remove its artificial constraints and create a genuinely portable computer.
(Bloomberg Opinion) -- Every now and then, I’ll be tempted by an iPad. I’ll spot some slick individual at a departure gate using one. Look at how neat it is, I’ll think, as I lug my laptop bag over my shoulder. It has great battery life and a built-in cellular connection, too!
Then, I’ll pull out my phone and look up some options. This is where the trouble begins. There is a boggling array of models and sizes, and the newness and benefits of each are not quite clear. I question the necessity of a $129 stylus, given that Steve Jobs once said he hated the idea. And I wonder, can this really replace my laptop and all I need it to do?
The answer to that question, 14 years after the iPad was first introduced, is still “almost.” Which, in practical terms, means no. And that’s the end of it.
On Tuesday, Apple will try to revive its iPad line during a “virtual event” it has called Let Loose. It is expected to bring the first significant update to the high-end iPad Pro since 2018. Investors hope it will reverse five consecutive quarters of negative iPad sales growth. This is a chance for a revival of a product that shows great promise but has always felt artificially constrained.
The iPad’s limitations are not technical. They are imposed by Apple for protectionist reasons: It still wants consumers to buy its MacBooks. As a result, the software experience is locked into a mobile-first operating system, making it more like a giant smartphone (less useful) than a small laptop (much more useful).
This is why if you ever see an iPad “in the wild,” it’s just as likely to be in the clutches of a toddler rather than a businessperson or student. Reinforced with a thick rubber case and loaded up with , the iPad is a terrific device for those younger than 10 in need of a distraction. Unfortunately for Apple, this consumer cohort is not particularly large, and parents have little need to update the iPad from one offspring to the next.
For adults, the iPad’s primary utility is basically the same. Aside from basic tasks like email, it’s a device through which users consume rather than create. This significantly limits its appeal. More recent enhancements, such as a highly capable keyboard and support for the use of a Bluetooth mouse, get things closer to the mark but still feel like a compromise. The iPad’s software is still “locked down” compared with Mac users’ freedom to install any software they desire. There are missing dedicated popular apps, like Instagram and WhatsApp, as well as the higher-end offerings from Adobe. All this makes an expensive tablet a tougher sell, given many will still need an expensive laptop to cover their bases.
The iPad’s identity crisis is getting renewed interest this year. On Apple’s troubled income statement — overall company revenue has fallen in five of the last six quarters — the iPad is particularly disappointing. Tuesday’s event will be a chance to show off the revived range. In addition to new models, as reported by Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman, Apple’s website teased an improved pencil that could erase more easily. Welcome to the future.
Apple should be bolder. As Gurman notes, the company’s restraint with the iPad has typically been to protect its MacBook business, but that’s struggling, too — barely ticking up in the last two quarters after sharp sales declines. If Apple doesn’t move quickly, others might try to step in. Data from Canalys suggests the global tablet market grew by 1% in the first quarter of this year, reversing four quarters of year-on-year decline. However, the growth has come from Apple’s competitors — the iPad’s global market share fell to 36% from 42% a year ago.
Similar data from IDC showed overall market improvement but a shrinking of iPad’s leading position. The global market share of Huawei, the Chinese maker whose devices cannot be bought in the US, jumped by a staggering 43.6%. (That said, the vast majority of consumers are still making a choice between an iPad or no tablet at all. Even highly capable rival tablets are a hard sell because they are outside of the Apple ecosystem.)
Tuesday’s announcement will spur sales. There will be pent-up demand from those who have wanted to update their iPads over the last year or more but knew that updates were just around the corner. They will surely be delighted by more powerful chips and a better screen. But still, the mass appeal of the iPad will remain sorely lacking until Apple throws off the shackles and creates a genuinely portable computer — the device that Jobs envisioned in 2010. The other parts of Apple’s business will be just fine. The AI age will bring about new demands for computing power, allowing the MacBook to remain a compelling product as a high-end workhorse for creatives and specialists.
An iPad powered by something closer to MacOS would bring about tantalizing new use cases. It would continue to act as a gateway device as Apple tries to sell consumers on the potential of so-called spatial computing while finally fully satisfying the more traditional demands of work and study. The time has come for Apple to move the needle from “almost” to “yes.”
More From Bloomberg Opinion’s Dave Lee:
- AI Is the Tie That Binds Frenemies Apple and Google
- If Apple Has Something Up Its Sleeve, Now’s the Time
- So Long, Apple Car, We’ll Never Know What We Missed
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Dave Lee is Bloomberg Opinion's US technology columnist. He was previously a correspondent for the Financial Times and BBC News.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion
©2024 Bloomberg L.P.
